Marrying the Captain
Grade : A-

Carla Kelly can do no wrong! It’s a rare treat to read a novel with the perfect blend of wit, charm, humility and intelligence. I could be referring to anything on Kelly’s backlist as they all fit the bill. But I am charged with reviewing Marrying the Captain. A sweeter job cannot be found.

Like most of Carla Kelly’s heroines, Nana Massie is down on her luck. The illegitimate daughter of a viscount, Nana ran away from her prim finishing school when she found out the plans her father had for her future. These past five years, Nana has lived with her grandmother in Plymouth helping run a none-too prosperous inn. The Mulberry Inn, far off the beaten path, has no lodgers and barely enough food to feed themselves. Nana resorts to visiting the more established merchants in town for charity. A surprise visit from a naval captain throws the Inn’s four inhabitants into an uproar, but this captain not only offers up money for his own meals, but for those of the entire house.

Captain Oliver Worthy is landlocked for a few weeks while his ship is repaired. While visiting his superiors in London, Oliver is asked a favor by Nana’s father. Not only a viscount, but a high-ranking naval officer to boot, Lord Ratcliffe feigns fatherly concern and wants Oliver to check up on his daughter to see how she fares. Oliver is hesitant - his trunks are already at his usual lodging - but when Ratcliffe pulls out the miniature of Nana, he is utterly captivated. He must see this vision in person so he agrees to the scheme, thinking it an innocuous task.

Now Oliver is in quite the predicament. As a life-long seaman, he vowed long ago that he would never open himself up to a loving relationship. He has seen too many widows made because of the war and the sea. But one look at Nana Massie and he is done for. Nana is equally as smitten with the kind, handsome Captain. She nurses him through a putrid throat, they share meals together, and he ingratiates himself into her small family’s life. Through these circumstances they fall even more in love.

From the title I’m sure you can guess where this is all leading, but it’s not an easy road. Even with two people who fall in love quickly and for all the right reasons, they have some obstacles. Because of her father and the harsh treatment Nana received at the finishing school, her illegitimate status leaves her insecure and feelings unworthy. Oliver is still fighting his solemn vow not to marry and the approaching departure of his ship to join the blockade. The country is also in the midst of a war, and even the most common English folks must be wary of potential spies.

I like to think of Carla Kelly’s heroines as friends. They do become quite close to the soul as their story unfolds before you. It isn’t hard to imagine a quaint sitting room with a few damaged, but restored ladies from previous books sitting about having a cup of tea. Roxana Drew and Jane Milton sitting down to a quiet conversation all the while Omega Chartley and Emma Costello are flying into the boughs about something or other. Nana Massie fits in with this bunch perfectly. I see Nana enjoying a spot of tea with the more serene Roxie and Miss Milton, but her eyes would drift to Omega and Emma more than once. Nana likes to think of herself as quiet and serene, yet there is an inner feistiness about her.

As for Captain Oliver Worthy… Truly, can Ms. Kelly write a bad hero? He is everything one would want in a man and then some. He is depicted as a stern man not known for his sense of humor, but Nana Massie brings out the best in him from the start. His demeanor softens, he smiles and even laughs occasionally. He is a true gentleman, but also a true man, succumbing to some naughty thoughts about the sweet Miss Massie. Some truly funny remarks ensued because of his traitorous mind.

The small, practically indecipherable minus next to the A up above is due to the secondary characters. Don’t get me wrong; Gran, Pete the old sailor and many others are delightful characters, but… It’s the problem that happens with spoiled children. They get used to a certain standard and won’t accept any less. I’m used to an above average supporting cast from Carla Kelly and that just didn’t happen here.

Except for the less than stellar (only slightly!) secondary characters, I couldn’t find a darn thing wrong with this enchanting tale of two people who never thought to find anyone special only to run smack into each other. Carla Kelly is on what I call my “grocery list.” This means, along with a select few others, I would read every word she writes - including her grocery list. Marrying the Captain is far from a grocery list. It’s one of her best love stories.

Reviewed by Lisa Gardineer
Grade : A-

Sensuality: Warm

Review Date : January 15, 2009

Publication Date: 2009

Recent Comments …

  1. Having that problem too – just now, hugely enjoyed Spite House by Olivia Dade, m/f CR done wonderfully. Strong rec.

  2. I really didn’t think you were criticising anyone, so we’re good! There was a discussion on AAR some time ago…

  3. But, queer romance are as real to me as non-queer, so I still don’t understand your thinking. I still want…

Lisa Gardineer

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
What's your opinion?x