A Practical Mistress
Grade : B

I'm not sure how I've managed to miss Mary Brendan. I picked up A Practical Mistress at the bookstore, thinking that the plot sounded interesting – but not really daring to hope that it would actually be good. My Regency reads of late have nearly all been disappointing. Happily, this one was a nice surprise, reminding me a bit of Signet Regencies in their glory days (with a little Sense and Sensibility thrown in).

The beginning of the plot is very Sense and Sensibility. Helen and Charlotte Marlowe are living in extreme poverty because their brother George refuses to give them the allowance that is rightfully theirs. They can't pay any bills and can barely heat their home. Meanwhile their brother's wife, Iris, is cuckolding him and racking up expenses. George's simple solution to the problem is to either put his sisters in a cheaper home (in an area known for housing noblemen's mistresses) or marry off the pretty, virginal Charlotte. Charlotte is currently seeing a young man who loves her, but as yet has few prospects, and Helen is loath to see her sister married off to a man she doesn't love.

When Helen hears that the sale of their family home is imminent, she pays a visit to Sir Jason Hunter (the buyer). Coincidentally, the nasty sister-in-law Iris has her sites set on Jason as her next conquest. When Helen arrives in Jason's home, he mistakenly believes she is Iris, and treats her shabbily. As she journeys home, her hackney nearly runs him over. He visits her in turn, trying to get to the bottom of what is happening. He is pretty appalled at what he sees. It's obvious that the sisters have very little to live on and are sorely mistreated by their brother. Helen believes that it's indirectly Jason's fault, because she thinks Jason is sleeping with Iris. Despite Helen's erroneous charges, Jason finds that he feels very protective toward Helen.

The sale of Helen's home goes through, but rather than putting her out on the street, Jason pays her bills and orders more supplies for her home. Helen believes that the most honorable and practical course is to become Jason's mistress. She's already a widow (her husband was a soldier who died in battle), so becoming Jason's paramour will sully her reputation only slightly. Besides, she can't help thinking that sleeping with Jason would be far from unpleasant.

Meanwhile, Jason finds that he is not quite satisfied with the idea of Helen as mistress. He'd really rather marry her. But she seems content to live with the memories of her dead husband, and tells him she has no plans to marry again. As they work out the details of their relationship, the hapless George gets himself into another scrape. He owes money to an obnoxious man who will forgive the debt if George allows him to either marry Charlotte or sleep with Helen. Jason and Helen will need to overcome this man's brash advances and the misunderstandings that ensue.

As I read this book, I couldn't help but compare it with another Harlequin Historical from this year, Diane Gaston's Innocence and Impropriety. Both have heroines who negotiate to become mistresses but end up as wives instead. Brendan took a plot that annoyed me greatly in Gaston's book – and really made it work. This is truly a mistress plot done right, in no small part because it avoids some of the pitfalls that can really tank a mistress romance. One of the most common problems with this type of plot is that the hero can come across as a big jerk who abuses his higher social status. Jason never does this; his intentions are honorable from the start. He's generous and considerate without being wimpy; his plot may be more Sense and Sensibility, but Jason is not unlike Mr. Darcy.

I also truly liked Helen. She is not always the nicest person. She accuses Jason of things that are not his fault (though her misunderstandings make sense). She's obviously not a shrinking violet. All the same, she is completely believable as a woman of her time. She thinks out her options carefully, and her decision to become Jason's mistress is not made lightly. It's delightful to see her practical choices spawn an unexpected (for her) romance and happy ending.

This book actually features several small misunderstandings, most of which are easily worked through. My single issue is with a misunderstanding that comes late in the book and is a bit annoying. Fortunately, it doesn't drag out for long, and all's well that ends well.

Over all, I found A Practical Mistress to be a pleasant surprise. It satisfied my need for a good, solid Regency like the ones I used to enjoy years ago. Though I've missed Mary Brendan up until now, you can bet I'll be watching for more from her in the future.

Reviewed by Blythe Smith
Grade : B

Sensuality: Subtle

Review Date : October 24, 2007

Publication Date: 2007/09

Review Tags: Mistress

Recent Comments …

Blythe Smith

I've been at AAR since dinosaurs roamed the Internet. I've been a Reviewer, Reviews Editor, Managing Editor, Publisher, and Blogger. Oh, and Advertising Corodinator. Right now I'm taking a step back to concentrate on kids, new husband, and new job in law...but I'll still keep my toe in the romance waters.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
0
What's your opinion?x
()
x