Mary Balogh wraps up her Ravenswood series with Always Remember, Ben’s story. The romance is wonderful, yet the slightly muted character of the heroine means this book isn’t my favorite Balogh novel in the series, but it’s still worth reading.

Ben Ellis (as previously established, the by-blow of the late Duke of Stratton, raised by his father’s wife as a part of the family) is a single father to a young daughter. The child is the result of his marrying his mistress when he discovered she was pregnant; he and Marjorie adored each other, but her sad passing from an illness has left him adrift. Now Ben and three-year-old Joy are headed for a summer vacation at Ravenswood.

Lady Jennifer Arden is a spinster at twenty-five, the sister of a duke, and due to a twisted right leg incurred during a childhood illness must ambulate with rudimentary crutches and other devices. Her family adores her and she’s forged many a friendship, but she has no prospects for a romance since she turned down a fortune-hunting duke. Jennifer and Ben meet when he stumbles upon her learning how to walk using a primitive crutch, and Ben decides to devote himself to making some better mobility devices for her. After making her a special shoe and brace to aid her walking, he starts pulling her out of her shell with jaunts outside of the home.

They are instantly attracted to one another, and Joy comes to love Jenny as well. With Ben’s help, Jenny begins to experience more and more of the world. She’s there for him when his mother’s family abruptly makes contact, causing him to worry about their ulterior motives toward himself and Joy. But he and Jenny come from inequal social positions, which mean they can never marry – or can they?

I’m not qualified to judge the author’s presentation of Jenny as a disabled person, but I found it decent, if fairly simplistic. I can, however, say that Jenny is a fully-fledged character all her own and not a plot’s morality lesson, and she wants to be more mobile and ambulatory. It’s her somewhat weaker personality that I found a bit lacking. It’s not that she’s insipid, it’s that she doesn’t feel as vibrant as Ben or any of the other characters around her.

I did feel as though there was a little too much focus on making Jenny abled – on her walking – instead of the other parts of being disabled, but that doesn’t factor into my grade, as it’s Jenny’s expressed want. The pain she goes through does feel realistically handled, as does the fact that her family feel the need to shelter her.

I will always love a widower who still adores his late wife, but isn’t afraid to love more people. Ben is an incredible character and one of my favorite heroes of the year. I loved his relationship with little Joy, who feels like a credible child, and generally enjoyed her antics in general.

Yet I honestly really wanted to read Marjorie and Ben’s love story instead of Jenny and Ben’s; the way Balogh sets up those early chapters and gives us a peek at Marjorie’s fiery sass, it’s hard not to want to spend more time with her instead of Jenny, who sometimes comes off as a little bit too much of an innocent milksop. Yet Balogh does a good job contrasting these two women and making Ben’s attraction to both of them make sense. And Jenny does grow into a stronger and more unique person over time.

Outside of the sweet romance, there is a lot of careful exploration of the importance of social status, and what that means to both characters. Ben has to struggle to figure out who he is within the scheme of his own family, while Jenny has to claim her independence and individuality. Both stories are quite compelling.

Always Remember isn’t perfect Balogh, but even imperfect Balogh is pretty good.

 

Lisa Fernandes

Lisa Fernandes

Lisa Fernandes is a writer, reviewer and recapper who lives somewhere on the East Coast. Formerly employed by Firefox.org and Next Projection, she also currently contributes to Women Write About Comics. Read her blog at http://thatbouviergirl.blogspot.com/, follow her on Twitter at http://twitter.com/thatbouviergirl or contribute to her Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/MissyvsEvilDead or her Ko-Fi at ko-fi.com/missmelbouvier
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

14 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
MJV

I don’t really mind when Mary Balogh revisits past characters in her books—sometimes it’s helpful, and if not, I just skip those bits and keep going. This time, I really didn’t mind because I hadn’t read the first two books in the series—I jumped right into this one since a heroine with a leg/foot problem hits close to home (my late mom lived with the effects of polio most of her life). Maybe that’s why I connected with Jenny and Ben’s love story. They’re the kind of couple you genuinely want to see happy together. Plus—Ben’s became one of my all-time favorite male leads from Balogh—in my top ten, at least.

That said, the book isn’t perfect. Here’s what bothered me most: there are way too many repeated thoughts throughout the story. I know Balogh’s style can be a bit like this, but here it felt too much. Also, as Lisa pointed ou in her review, I wish Jenny was more fleshed out beyond her disability and how she copes socially. We see how she struggles a lot with what she’s lost, but it her character was a bit narrow. We’re made to like—and even love—her, but it’s like the story stops just when you start to see her real self peek through. I wanted more of her setting into her new life, as a mom and wife and “independent” woman.

I also agree with Lisa Fernandes that a love story between Majorie and Ben would’ve been great. But it seems Balogh prefers noble characters over commoners, and the Ware family fits that. Maybe one day, after the Ravenwood series, we’ll get a fiery, sassy heroine paired with a most decent guy caught up in the Peninsula battlefields—here’s hoping! 

(I’m currently panicking a little, since Balogh is in her 80s. Her novels have brought me tons of enjoyable hours of reading. From my account, more than 85 novels, plus other smaller works!)

For my mom’s memory and the joy I get from reading Balogh (quirks and all), I’m giving this one a B+, same as Lisa. :)

MJV

Another small comment. The family tree in the beginning of the novel is quite useful, but I think Mary Balogh could light her text descriptions a bit if she presented a list of characters as well.

Brontesrule

I haven’t read this one yet, but checked to see if any more books would be forthcoming. Balogh has said she hopes to have seven books in this series, so hopefully that hasn’t changed.

Kayne Spooner

I enjoyed your review and thought this was a sweet story. I loved how happy Jenny was when Ben was teaching her to drive a carriage. The hardest part for me is remembering all the names of the brothers, sisters, cousins, and friends – there were so many of them in the story.

Dabney Grinnan

I find the vast cast a tough sell in current Balogh.

KitBee

Same here! I’ve read both of the previous Ravenswood books and was turned off by the huge cast of characters — they really detracted from the central romances and just felt like sequel bait. I’m generally a Balogh fan, though, so I’m sticking with the series for now. Glad to see the positive review and comments here!

Marian Perera

You were not kidding. I tried reading the excerpt, and was introduced to Devlin, the Earl of Stratton, Gwyneth Rhys, his wife, the daughter of Sir Ifor and Lady Rhys, Devlin’s son Gareth, Viscount Montford, Lady Phillippa Ware, now the Duchess of Wilby, her husband Lucas, Ben Ellis, Devlin’s half-brother, Major the Honorable Nicholas Ware, Devlin’s brother, Owen Ware, yet another brother, Viscount Watley, Owen’s friend, Lady Catherine Emmett, a friend of Clarissa, the Dowager Countess of Stratton, and Lady Catherine’s niece, Lady Jennifer Arden. All this before the end of the first chapter, before the hero and heroine had even met, and before there was any hint of conflict that would rope me in and keep me hooked through the massive dramatis personae. I loved Balogh’s The Secret Pearl and A Precious Jewel but her later books have been difficult reads for me and I don’t think I’ll stick with this one.

Last edited 2 years ago by Marian Perera
Caz Owens

That’s a crazy number of characters to put in an opening chapter! Especially if most of them aren’t relevant to the story or will ever be seen again. The last series of MB’s I read – the one before last I think – was 7 or 8 books long, so that by the time you got to book 8, there were a lot of previous couples to catch up with, but they weren’t all just dumped in at the beginning!

Marian Perera

It gives me the impression that this book is for fans of the series who already know who these characters are, rather than for newcomers to the series like me (or, for that matter, readers who might not remember who all the characters are).

LeeB.

I am a fan of her series books but the previous book came out in June. I can’t imagine anyone remembering all of the characters unless they created a spreadsheet. And I agree with Caz that most of them aren’t even relevant to the story. There is a family tree at the beginning of the book so she didn’t need to provide all the additional character names.

Dabney Grinnan

Whoa.

Lisa Fernandes

There is a LOT going on in this book and I know she’s going for a family saga feeling but it is A Lot to figure out who’s who. I figure, though, that readers know what they’re getting into at this point, since all the Ravenswoods series books are like this.

nblibgirl

Balogh was an autobuy author for me at one time and several of her titles are definite sentimental favorites that I revisit regularly. I’ve been distracted in the last decade or more by other authors and themes, who I prioritize reading over Balogh these days. And I haven’t put any of her titles in any of my Best of Year lists for quite a while, but I think you say it pretty well Lisa: even an imperfect Balogh is still a pretty good read. Especially for people looking for historical romance. Balogh has been publishing 1-2 HR titles a year since the 1980s, a pretty amazing track record!
Your review makes me want to read this one ;-) so thanks!

Lisa Fernandes

I hope you like it – it’s really enjoyable!