Desert Isle Keeper

Lady Sophia's Lover (#96 on AAR's Top 100 Romances)

Lisa Kleypas

An AAR Top 100 Romance

originally published on May 3, 2002


We all know those writers who recycle their heroes. And our opinions of those writers are almost solely based on whether we like – or don’t like – her particular trademark guy.

Lisa Kleypas is a different kind of writer, one with an amazing ability to create achingly real heroes who virtually all vary dramatically in age, background, and personality. But, despite their differences, all of them share one very important quality – the ability to both touch the heart and stimulate the senses. And, boy, can they stimulate the senses.

As the creator of Derek Craven, Lord Alex Raiford, and Jack Devlin, Ms. Kleypas has set the bar impossibly high, something she must feel acutely with each new book. But, clearly, the well is far from running dry. Because in direct contrast to the delicious younger man in last year’s Suddenly You, Lisa Kleypas now offers burning, smoldering proof that 40 really is fabulous. Ladies, prepare to meet Sir Ross Cannon, intrepid head of the Bow Street Runners.

Maybe the key is in the small, personal details. Sir Ross is a bit thin because he often just can’t find the time to eat. He is a devoted son to his flighty society mother. He is so dedicated to his position that he will even chase a criminal over rooftops – to truth, justice, and the English way. He keeps unflattering caricatures of himself on his bedroom wall. He is a cranky patient and a great trial to anyone tending his sickbed. And, most importantly, he is one of those guys who doesn’t like to admit that he is anything less than perfectly controlled at all times.

But from the moment Lady Sophia applies in person for the job as his assistant at Bow Street, Ross is motivated less by good sense and more by his own senses. Clearly, his days as the “Monk of Bow Street” are numbered.

Sophia, of course, has her own reasons for wanting to work for our noble hero, reasons that have given her the deepest feelings of hatred for Sir Ross. It seems that some years earlier Ross, then a magistrate, sentenced her brother to serve time on a prison hulk for petty stealing – a sentence that ultimately led him to contract a fatal case of cholera. Sophia’s plan is to use her position as Ross’s assistant to gain access to the Bow Street files and records where, she believes, she will discover evidence of Ross’s abuse of his authority, evidence she plans to use to destroy him. And, if she can also make him fall in love with her and eventually break his heart, well, then, all the better.

Of course, things don’t work out quite the way Sophia plans. Proximity to the incredible Ross leads her to see that he is, well, the incredible Ross. And, of course, the two eventually become lovers.

I have to say that the revenge plot certainly isn’t one of my favorites and, frankly, the big surprise is easy to predict. But the characters here (and did you get by now that I really liked Ross?) are so fabulous, the love scenes so sexy, the dialogue between the two lovers so beautiful, that, frankly, none of that matters. Sophia is a woman with a bit of a past and she is also a woman of substance and fortitude. And, even though she makes a few bad decisions during the course of the story, ultimately, she actually deserves Ross. And that is saying something.

The main attraction of this book is watching this strong, powerful, fundamentally noble man (who first made his appearance in Someone To Watch Over Me) succumb completely to love. And, while Kleypas is an author who writes fairly graphic – and extremely enjoyable – love scenes, the emphasis is always on romance. For my money, that’s where it belongs.

Once again, Ms. Kleypas has added another major league hero to her pantheon of greats. And though I know Sir Ross Cannon isn’t real, I’m profoundly grateful to the author for letting me imagine for a few hours that he might be.

Buy Lady Sophia’s Lover:

Buy from Amazon.com      Get it on iBooks      Nook      Kobo     

Book Details

Reviewer :      Sandy Coleman

Grade :     A

Sensuality :      Hot

Book Type :     

Review Tags :      |

Recent Comments


  1. Dabney Grinnan
    Dabney Grinnan July 4, 2017 at 12:32 pm - Reply

    I don’t recall being wowed by this book. It had too much of a Big Mis for me. But I’ve not read it in years.

    • Caz Owens
      Caz Owens July 4, 2017 at 12:47 pm - Reply

      Same here on both counts. I liked it and Ross really is pretty awesome but Sophia didn’t make much of an impression on me and I seem to recall some close to TSTL moments on her part.

  2. Blackjack
    Blackjack July 4, 2017 at 4:57 pm - Reply

    Not one of my favorites from Kleypas either back when I was still reading her books. Not enough substance in the story itself and a bland heroine as well.

  3. mel burns July 4, 2017 at 5:19 pm - Reply

    This was my first Kleypas so I have found memories of it, but Sophia was a little TSTL at times.

  4. HopefulPuffin July 4, 2017 at 6:02 pm - Reply

    This was a DNF for me and since it’s Kleypas, that’s saying something. I’m not sure what it was about it but I couldn’t connect with either character. I was ticked off because of all the glowing Ross reviews.

  5. Edna July 6, 2017 at 3:43 pm - Reply

    First time, loved it. Next time, a few years later, DNF. Back when I loved it, it was one of the first romances I’d read as an adult, so I was just gobbling up everything I came across. During the DNF reread, besides Sophia being TSTL, the writing seemed really weighed down by overuse of the passive voice. Basically, the book went from DIK to DNF.

Leave A Comment