Fairest of Them All
Grade : C-

In Fairest of Them All, Josette Browning has written an updated nineteenth century potboiler, reminiscent of Edgar Rice Boroughs' Tarzan of the Apes with a Pygmalion twist. This highly unusual romance novel imitates a Victorian popular novel including its sensibilities about sex and social rank. The result makes for a sometimes disturbing read.

The book opens in 1871, with the "wild child," Talitha Rowen, being presented to physician Daniel Canty as a challenge. Take this child, raised by wild dogs in Africa and turn her into a young lady fit to debut in Society. There's twenty thousand pounds in it for Daniel, if he can manage to civilize her. Talitha cannot or will not speak and acts like a wild animal. Incidentally, she is the daughter of an earl.

Daniel Canty, twenty-nine, is a terrific Victorian hero. A self made man, physician and barrister who has worked his way up to the middle class, Daniel nevertheless believes in the idea of superior blood - that the classes are separated not just by custom, but by differences that have been bred into them. By any measure, Daniel's own success should have proved to him that his ideas about class heredity are incorrect. As she grows up, Talitha sees Daniel's superiority even when he, devoted to his own theories, cannot.

In the first half of the book, Talitha grows up in Daniel's house. He struggles to get her to talk and behave in a conventional manner. Because Talitha is a child, there is no romance in this part of the novel and some of it drags. Then, Talitha goes through puberty. When Daniel realizes that he is physically attracted to Talitha, it is shocking. She is bathing outdoors and he comes upon her naked. The combination of Talitha's juvenile thoughts and childlike body, not to mention Daniel's father-like role until that point, disturbed me greatly. It does not help that Daniel has a sweet devoted mistress at the beginning of the book with whom he seems far better suited, both in age and custom, but whom he does not love. For a time I hoped that Daniel would choose his mistress.

Finally after two years, Talitha is presented to society and assumes her rightful title and fortune. Daniel ejects her abruptly and cruelly from his house and life. He feels the two can never be together because of the difference in their ranks. This reason would have satisfied Victorian readers who were used to stories where class was a barrier. For them, Talitha's age and childish perspective would not have presented an impediment to marriage as it would today.

The second half of Fairest of Them All covers the ensuing two years when, Talitha, living on her own and having matured, tries to persuade Daniel to be honest about his feelings. The relationship between the two is sexually charged but something indefinable is missing. They honestly have no common ground, and one wonders what these two will talk about when things cool off. The final resolution of the story is a surprise that I won't give away. In an odd way it is victory for Daniel's narrow thinking.

Despite my problems with this book, there was a lot to like about it, though not as a romance novel. The period feeling was very good as was the historical research. Many secondary characters are memorable including: Talitha's evil governess, Elspeth, the wise old housekeeper, Mrs. Potter and Daniel's dove-like mistress Lady Jane.

According to the inside cover this is Josette Browning's first romance novel. I didn't always enjoy Fairest of Them All but I had to respect the risks Browning took in presenting an unusual story. I hope that Josette Browning keeps writing. I have a feeling she has some extraordinary books in her.

Reviewed by Robin Uncapher
Grade : C-

Sensuality: Warm

Review Date : May 2, 1999

Publication Date: 1999

Review Tags: Pygmalion Victorian

Recent Comments …

Robin Uncapher

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
0
What's your opinion?x
()
x