
Instructions for Dancing
Instructions for Dancing blew me away while asking some very deep and thought-provoking questions, and yet it also has a deft, gentle touch. It is a heavy book; it hurts the reader’s heart and yet lifts them up, and will provide young readers with a signpost towards developing an understanding the bumps and heartbreaks ahead of them.
Evie Thomas is a one-time romantic whose entire worldview has been skewed by her parent’s divorce on the heels of her father’s infidelity. She used to love to read and was a huge fan of romance novels, but when stricken with the bitter reality of the imperfection of love, she’s understandably embittered. The appearance of a sudden magical power does not uncomplicate things.
While out one afternoon, Evie witnesses a couple kissing, and flashes through scenes of their relationship from the start to its bitter end. It happens again, the next time she sees a couple kiss. Unsure of what this means, she tries to explore the situation, but in the meantime she bumps into a boy outside of a dance academy while attempting to return a book she discovered in a little library box to its original owner. Pressed into a dance battle – which she and her new partner win – she’s further tempted into spending time attending dance lessons at La Brea Dance Studio. The artistic X, who dragged her into that dance battle, remains her partner.
Evie and X have a lot of dance-floor chemistry with one another, but he is her polar opposite; while Evie is cautious, X is bold and adventurous. With his encouragement, they jump into a ballroom dance competition. But will her glimpses into the future they might have together pull them apart or bring them together?
As Yoon warns at the beginning of Instructions for Beginners, this is not a romance. Rather, this is a tale about Evie figuring out how to believe in the concept of love even though she knows it might end. It asks if love is a worthwhile concept in and of itself when it’s not fairytale perfect. So while the book is not a love story – it also kind of is, because Evie and X do love one another wholeheartedly. But really, it’s about the concept. The awe-inspiring possibility of love and the heavy, awkward weight it can leave behind on a person’s shoulders.
I liked bookish Evie, and how X brings her out of her shell and helps her connect to the musical world and teaches her how to dance. I liked passionate X, whose lack of fear is admirable and whose pursuit of art and adventure is delightful. I liked how the book humanizes Evie’s father and his decisions, and explores Evie’s emotions about him proposing to and falling in love with another woman and how they get along. I enjoyed the way it portrays Evie’s mother’s distraught, complicated feelings about the situation. The book’s wholly realistic portrayal of how hard and scary and yet worthwhile love can be is beautiful.
I couldn’t find much fault with this story. Instructions For Dancing is a valuable book, a touching one, and a great piece of art. It’s Yoon’s best novel yet.





This sounds like a really interesting book! Thanks for the review.
I’ve thought for a decade or more that some of the most interesting fiction being published today is in the YA market segment (to the point that even a few authors are occasionally surprised their books end up with that label).
YA has really been having a gangbuster declade honestly.
* decade
“So while the book is not a love story – it also kind of is, because Evie and X do love one another wholeheartedly”
Usually “It’s a love story, not a romance” is a cop-out you see when an author is trying to get romance dollars but the literary cred genre fiction repels like the wrong end of a magnet. I come to AAR because I trust you guys will tell me what to expect, and not what marketing thinks will make me buy. So can you tell me – explicitly – do Evie and X get together at the end of the book?
While in a regular line romance you can naturally expect a HEA ending, YA and WF and Fiction will be all over the map. I’m naturally reluctant to give major spoilers in the body of a review as it will prevent readers from finding out for themselves what happens in the book, especially in a book like this, but since you asked:
Wow. Very glad to have that info. Thanks for telling me.
Thanks for the great review. I’ve been thinking about reading this for awhile and this discussion has definitely moved it up on my TBR pile.
Hope you enjoy it!