Desert Isle Keeper
Part of me is always afraid to reread an old favorite, especially if I originally read it in my pre-reviewing days. What if it doesn’t measure up? What if it’s not as good as I remembered? With Paradise, I needn’t have worried. I started it during a week when I had about a million other things to do, but even with countless distractions, all I wanted to do was read this book – even though I already knew what was going to happen! Still, there I was, up till all hours of the night, laughing and crying in the same places I’d laughed and cried the first time.
Paradise is the story of a young man and woman in love who are cruelly parted. It’s also the story of the people they become eleven years later, both of them confident and powerful CEOs. Readers may be tempted to dismiss it as just another book about misunderstandings or millionaires, but that would be a real mistake, because there’s so much more.
McNaught refuses to take shortcuts, and the book begins when Meredith Bancroft is an awkward adolescent. She’s chubby with stick straight hair and horrible clothes that make her look completely unsophisticated. As the only daughter of a man who owns a prestigious Chicago department store, she is more comfortable with adults than kids her own age, and her dream is to follow in her father’s footsteps and run Bancroft’s someday. We glimpse her again four years later as she graduates from high school. She’s outgrown the baby fat, but she’s still chafing against her strict father’s unreasonable demands. He thinks women should confine their activities to charity balls and child rearing, and he wants to send her to a college that’s little more than a finishing school. One night after a particularly upsetting argument, she attends a country club event and meets Matt Farrell. Matt’s background couldn’t be more different. He’s from the wrong side of the tracks, and he put himself through school by working in a steel mill while supporting his family and paying off his deceased mother’s medical bills. But Matt’s got big plans; he’s about to work for one of the country club’s patrons for two years in Venezuela. His goal is to take the $150,000 bonus he will receive and invest it, so that he can increase his wealth.
But one thing leads to another, and Meredith ends up pregnant with Matt’s child. She comes to see him at his family farm in Indiana, and they decide to get married. Matt’s plans didn’t include a wife and child, but he feels himself falling for Meredith, he thinks that it just might work. But when they confront Meredith’s father with the news, he is furious and vows to end the marriage. After he offers Matt money to walk away – which Matt coldly refuses – he appears to consent to the marriage, as long as Meredith stays in America during her pregnancy.
Then comes the misunderstanding to end all misunderstandings, and you can really see it coming. Meredith’s father interferes with their mail, so neither she nor Matt receives all the letters the other has written. Then Meredith’s pregnancy takes a dangerous turn and she loses the baby. As she is lying there, sick with pain and grief, asking every second for Matt, her father sends Matt a telegram telling him Meredith has had an abortion and wants a divorce. When Matt flies home from Venezuela to see her, Meredith’s father has him barred from the hospital. He then handles the quickie divorce, and both Meredith and Matt eventually get on with their lives.
Eleven years later, Matt is the CEO of Intercorp, a huge conglomerate which he founded that buys and sells other companies. Meredith is a vice president at Bancroft’s with her eye on the president’s chair. Their paths cross again when Matt buys a Chicago electronics company, and while both of them have gotten on with their lives, both bear scars from their traumatic marriage. Meredith cuts Matt cold at first, but then her fiancé makes the horrible discovery that her divorce was invalid, and she is still legally married to Matt. Of course the reader can see already that these two are perfect for each other and destined to live happily ever after, but it will take some doing for Matt and Meredith to reach that point. Aside from the years of misunderstanding and bitterness, they have problems involving their respective businesses, families, and relationships. And just when it looks like they are about to overcome their tragic past, they have an eleventh hour crisis that could tear them apart forever.
As I read Paradise this time through, I thought a lot about what makes it so special. One thing I truly appreciated is that McNaught doesn’t skimp on the reader. This book is over seven hundred pages long, and not a page is wasted. We are allowed to see Meredith as an awkward preteen, and we fully experience Matt and Meredith’s early romance. Frankly, I doubt a new author today could get such a long book published. I’m sure she would be told to reveal the early romance in flashback, which would have taken a lot of the power out of it. As it is we become thoroughly attached to Matt and Meredith before their tragic parting, which makes their separation much more poignant.
While most Big Misunderstandings make me grit my teeth in annoyance, Matt and Meredith’s Big Mis is a fundamental strength of the book. So often a misunderstanding is rooted in something truly idiotic, like the hero catching the heroine hugging another man, whom any idiot (except him) can tell is her brother. But the Big Mis here is perpetrated, believably, by Meredith’s controlling father. Matt and Meredith are in love, but they are both naïve, and both fail to understand just how far her father is willing to go to separate them. The three hanky scene in which Meredith miscarries and calls and calls for Matt is utterly heartbreaking. It always reminds me of a similar scene in Gone With the Wind, which, come to think of it, also occurs after a miscarriage. Scarlett calls for Rhett, and nobody hears her; Rhett is in another room wishing and wishing that she would call his name. Every time I read it I want to insert myself in the book somehow and fix things, which is just how I feel with Matt and Meredith. The payoff comes in the incredibly touching scene when Meredith finds out about her father’s deception and tells Matt the truth. The intense emotional power of this moment gets me every time.
But perhaps the real reason this book works so well is that the characters are lovable and real. Yes, they are both stunning, and yes, they are both rich. But both are the kind of people you can root for. They both have to overcome prejudice; Matt has his impoverished past, and Meredith has a controlling father with an unfair gender bias. When Meredith and Matt are together, they truly enjoy each other’s company, even when they are in the midst of their misconceptions about each other. They are flanked by a cast of secondary characters who really add to the story, and their respective business scenes are always interesting.
I’ve enjoyed most of McNaught’s books, but Paradise is my favorite. This is a book that will make you cry buckets, but it will also make you believe in the power of love. Matt and Meredith endure heartbreaking loss, and eventually find joy in each other. Rereading it reminded me of all the things I love about romance. It is truly one of the best the genre has to offer.
I've been at AAR since dinosaurs roamed the Internet. I've been a Reviewer, Reviews Editor, Managing Editor, Publisher, and Blogger. Oh, and Advertising Corodinator. Right now I'm taking a step back to concentrate on kids, new husband, and new job in law...but I'll still keep my toe in the romance waters.
|Review Date:||February 11, 2001|
|Book Type:||Contemporary Romance|
|Review Tags:||businesswoman | Top 100 Romance|
I love your books Judith McNaught! I am almost about about to finish your book collections. Cheers!
I just finished this book and I was completely blown away by the character development by JM! It’s so beautifully planned and what strikes me having read few of her novels is the characters always stays true to their initial identities. Unlike other books, her characters are flawed at the same time quite admiring. I love how dreamy the hero’s are and how humble heroines are. In paradise I found myself enjoying every page which I thought o wouldn’t because of the detail in the plot on their business world! I would say the book taught me and it was reassuring about how true love actually lingers in the heart despite time and distance. Totally one of my fav and definitely an enjoyable read. I give this book a 4.5 star!
Is the ending sad or happy ?
My fav romance novel of all time! Great review!
My top 100 books have gone through lots of changes over the years, but the top two have been consistent for the last 20 years: #1 Paradise, #2 A Kingdom of Dreams. Nobody does it better than McNaught.
paradise and perfect are my all time favourites , have reread them many times
McNaught is a problematic author for me – so well-reviewed by so many for so many years – too often I found myself wondering why. But I have both this and Perfect on my (literal keeper) shelves. (I read a lot of romances but the only ones I keep are ones I think may be worth a reread at some point.) Might be time to go back and see how it/they hold up before I shuffle my own list of Top 100.
Paradise was very good but Perfect is my favorite story. I seldom read a book more than once. But Perfect is a book I have read at least once a year.
I liked Paradise a lot but I definitely preferred its sequel, Perfect. I also wished that McNaught had written a full length romance between two of Paradise’s secondary characters, Meredith’s ex-fiance Parker and her best friend Lisa. That relationship seemed to me to have enormous potential, and it deserved a novel of its own.
This has always been my favorite Judith McNaught book. I agree that the page length is integral to the story. So many books published today barely reach 300 pages and that’s often not enough for character and plot development.
That’s a very good point, Kim- I agree wholeheartedly.
McNaught was my gateway author. I snuck Paradise and Perfect into basic training many moons ago. I remember stealing reading breaks in the bathroom stalls, probably what kept me sane. I’m afraid of re reading because I don’t want to tarnish those memories.
She is my gateway author too! I’ve reread both novels and find Paradise holds up well, but Perfect not so much.
My previous library had the entire series in hardback (!) and I enjoyed them all. I am sooo tempted to bite the bullet and pay the price so I can enjoy them all again.