The Science of Attraction

This third book in the author’s Mackenzie Country series – set in and around a couple of remote sheep stations in the stunning Southern Alps of New Zealand – is an emotional love story about self-discovery and stepping up to fulfil expectations and make the life you want.

The focus in this book shifts from the folks at Miller Station to those at the neighbouring Lane Station. Its owner, Paddy Lane, is a curmudgeonly old git, an autocratic bigot whose rampant and often expressed homophobia was the reason his younger son, Zach, hid the fact that he was gay until around a year earlier, and is what has kept his older son, Julian (Jules), firmly in the bisexual closet.

At the end of the previous book (The Mechanics of Lust), Zach, Jules, and Zach’s boyfriend, Luke, risked their lives to rescue Paddy when he had a major stroke after stubbornly heading out on a treacherous track alone. The old man is lucky to be alive and has recently returned home after five months in hospital and at a rehabilitation facility, months during which Jules took over the running of the station and implemented a number of changes that are making a big difference to the lives of everyone who works there. For years, Paddy has ruled the place with a rod of iron, his intractable demeanour and insistence that he’s always right not making for the happiest working environment, but now Jules has stepped in, that ever-present cloud of oppression has lifted, and his sound business sense and genuine, deep-rooted love for the land and the work have earned him a lot of respect and fostered a real sense of camaraderie among the workers. Now Paddy is home he expects things to go back to the way they were, but Jules is having none of it. Paddy isn’t physically or mentally fit enough to be able to do all the things he used to, and Jules is determined to prevent the business from backsliding as a result of his father’s questionable decisions and abrasive, uncompromising manner.

Jules had hoped that he and Zach would run Lane Station together one day, but with Zach living happily on Miller Station and in the process of setting up his own dog-training business, Jules has stepped up, and the past five months have been both challenging and invigorating. This is what he’s meant to do with his life and everything is going exactly as it’s supposed to – until the day Liam Skelton shows up and every thought Jules has had about himself and about the direction his life is taking flies right out the window.

Jules has known he’s bisexual since he was a teenager, and as he’s always been far more attracted to women than men, he hasn’t seen the point in rocking the boat. But there’s something about Liam – with his striking good-looks and air of confidence – that absolutely does it for Jules and makes him start to wonder what it would be like to be with someone he can be fully himself with.

Liam, an occupational therapist, has been employed to help Paddy to improve his speech and mobility, and will be staying on the station for the duration of his seven-week contract. Needless to say, the old man isn’t happy at having his “gay arse in charge of his rehab.” The first few days are awkward, to say the least, until Liam confronts Paddy’s prejudice head on and makes it clear that he’s a professional and expects to be treated as one. The uneasy truce that develops between them surprises everybody on the station; Paddy is never going to wave a rainbow flag, but he does at least start to show Liam the respect he deserves.

The principal storyline revolves around Jules working through his complicated feelings about his sexuality and figuring out how to balance his desire for Liam with his desire to continue to run Lane Station. Paddy threw Zach out when he told them he was gay, and Jules has been reluctant to be the cause of any further family fractures, so at first, he tries hard to fight his intense attraction to Liam. He’s the first and only man who has ever produced this kind of reaction in Jules, and as he’s only going to be around for a few weeks, getting involved with him would be only be asking for trouble. But Jules has never felt so powerfully attracted to anyone, ever… and he knows he’s fighting a losing battle.

The Science of Attraction is very much Jules’ story in the sense that his character is more strongly defined than Liam’s and he experiences the most character growth. I liked Liam – he’s very obviously good at his job and he’s generous, down-to-earth and wonderfully supportive – but I don’t feel as though I got to know him as well as I did Jules.

The romance here is as sexy and well-developed as I’ve come to expect in a Jay Hogan book. Her characters often fall in lust (and into bed) fairly quickly, but she always takes that as a starting point and takes time to build a deep and meaningful emotional connection between them as the story progresses. The chemistry between Jules and Liam is electric from the get-go and I enjoyed their love story, but it’s a bit ‘sex-heavy’; the author really knows how to write a sizzling sex scene, but there are a lot of them here and I have to admit that after the first few, they started to feel like padding. And while I really appreciated the thoughtful way Jules’ situation unfolds, the storyline sometimes feels stretched a little thin for the page count.

And for all the family drama, this is a fairly low-angst read. There is mention early on that Liam isn’t a relationship kind of guy, but we’re not given a reason for that other than that he likes his own space, and whatever concerns he might have had in the past don’t appear to be a problem for him when it comes to Jules. So the main conflict in the story arises from Paddy’s homophobia, leading to Jules’ fears that being with the man he loves may lead to his losing his home and the future he’s worked so hard for – and the only other real obstacle is that Jules and Liam need to work out how they can make a life together given Liam isn’t local and his job generally requires him to travel.

Once again, Jay Hogan transports readers to the gorgeous scenery of the Mackenzie Basin and into the daily lives of the workers on the remote sheep stations there. The descriptions of the landscape are vivid and evocative, and the intricacies of the day-to-day lives of the close-knit team of workers are superbly written. There’s an expertly drawn secondary cast here, some of whom we’ve met before – including Spencer, the local vet (whose book is up next) – and some who are new – like Liam’s nephew Connor – and they all add considerably to the overall sense of community and sincere friendship the author has created.

The Science of Attraction is a steamy, heartfelt romance filled with Jay Hogan’s trademark warmth, insight and down-to-earth humour. It doesn’t quite reach the heights of the first two books in the series, but it’s an excellent addition nonetheless.

Caz Owens

Caz Owens

I’m a musician, teacher and mother of two gorgeous young women who are without doubt, my finest achievement :)I’ve gravitated away from my first love – historical romance – over the last few years and now read mostly m/m romances in a variety of sub-genres. I’ve found many fantastic new authors to enjoy courtesy of audiobooks - I probably listen to as many books as I read these days – mostly through glomming favourite narrators and following them into different genres.And when I find books I LOVE, I want to shout about them from the (metaphorical) rooftops to help other readers and listeners to discover them, too.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

18 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Manjari

So I was behind on my Jay Hogan and just read all 3 Mackenzie Country books this weekend. I liked them all a lot, including this one. I will offer a dissenting opinion that I don’t think the number of sex scenes in The Science of Attraction is significantly different than in the first 2 books. What I really liked the most was that the main characters had honest discussions about their feelings and where they wanted the relationship to go. This was less so in The Mechanics of Lust (Zach was emotionally a runner) but well done in The Science of Attraction and even better done in The Art of Husbandry. The setting was described beautifully in each book and I loved how the shepherds were actually so romantic. I do think that in The Science of Attraction, the last act event veered into unnecessary melodrama but that was my only criticism. I felt the family dynamics were well done and felt realistic. I’m looking forward to the next book about Spencer and hope there will be one about Roz as well!

Edna

Finished earlier today. More of a B for me. Agree that there was a lot of filler in this one and I found myself paging forward, which I’ve never done with JH. It made me yearn for earlier JH novels that exhibited more showing, more intensity of feeling, tighter scenes. I, too, am looking forward to stepping outside the brothers and exes tangle.

Edna

even a not-quite-DIK-level Jay Hogan is head and shoulders above so much other contemporary romance out there

Hundred percent agree.

Lisa Fernandes

On the TBR!

BeckyK

Thanks for the review, Caz. I, too, am a Jay Hogan fan, so I am sure I’ll read this one at some point. I love the Mackenzie Country setting. However, I kinda wish we didn’t have to deal with Paddy, the homophobic dad, in another book. I’m not interested in him or any kind of a redemption arc for him. I would rather she let Luke be straight and move on to the vet, but she didn’t ask me!

Carrie G

I was thinking those very thoughts before reading this, plus I’m not big on family drama in my books. I have to say that while the tension is there and Paddy has a decent role in the book, it doesn’t overwhelm the story. I think because he is in a weakened state his presence isnt’ as intimidating as it was before. I actually thought his semi-redemptive arc was well done.
That said, and even though I really liked Jules and Liam together, I still kind of wish she’s taken a different MC for this, like Spencer, if only because having these clusters of gay men starts to feel very insular and unreal. Spencer was already set up as bi, and he would be an interesting character.

Carrie G

Yay about Spencer’s book!
Several of my kids are queer, although not all in the same way. (One trans, one bi, etc.) I’ve been told on more than one occasion I must be a terrible mom to have warped my kids so badly because of this. ::shrugs:: I’ve even been told I belong in jail. I’m not sure how we were corrupting since my husband and I are straight. We just modeled acceptance.

BeckyK

Carrie, I am so sorry to hear your family has been subjected to such ignorant and hateful comments. And based on your comments here, I am not surprised that you modeled acceptance. Your kids are lucky to have had you to raise them and not someone who would hate who they are, like Paddy, or even worse.
Back to Jay Hogan, I am really happy Spencer’s story is up next. That will give space for his family to be introduced. The problem with stories about siblings, is if you didn’t like the family in the first story, then that makes the next less appealing. Glad there isn’t too much Paddy in The Science of Attraction.

Carrie G

Thank you! We raised our kids in a pretty conservative church, but when they came out it was never a choice not to keep loving them. (We ended up leaving church altogether eventually.) My husband and I had never been homophobic anyway, as we were raised to accept people. That doesn’t mean there haven’t been some adjustments– having a trans child means flipping a lot of “history” in your brain, but we’ve tried to adapt.
I think the redemption arc for Paddy worked for me because

spoiler
Lieselotte

I am glad that parents exist in the world that create the safe space for each child to find their own truth, and allow them to live who or what they really are – you are a gift to the world.

And I am sorry that you experience such ugliness from some people.

Carrie G

Thank you!

Dabney Grinnan

I find that horrifying. I live in a town where I can’t imagine anyone saying that for which I am grateful.

I will say that, statistically, the acceptance of queer kids has risen dramatically in our lifetimes and for that I am also grateful.

Carrie G

Yes, the area we live in, espeically where you live, is pretty accepting. My kids use Duke Medical for all their healthcare, and I can’t say enough good things about how wonderfully they train their staff, medical and administrative. Everyone is welcoming and open. You can set your pronouns and prefered name in the system, and check in with that name (and an ID), so no one is dead-named. They are the same about weight issues, addressing it if needed for medical reasons but in nonjudgemental and respectful ways. We’re not happy with the way this state is going politically, and we’re trying to decide whether to stay here once my husband retires in a couple of years, but having such great medical care is a real draw to stay.

Last edited 2 years ago by Carrie G
Dabney Grinnan

I’ve had my medical care there since I was 18. The best.

Carrie G

Great review! I just finished this and really enjoyed it. Jay Hogan writes so well and so consistently that she’s become my favorite writer of contemporary romances. I’m looking back on her last 3 series (9 books) and there isn’t a dud in the bunch. And honestly, I can go backwards to Southern Lights and Aukland Med, too!
I agree with your impressions of this book. It wasn’t as complex emotionally as the previous two in the series, and while there were definite obstacles, the stakes somehow didn’t seem as high. I also thought there were a few too many sex scenes, even as good as they are! I did like all the conversations between the men that often happened around those sexy times. I loved that there is no big mis. I’ve also given this a B+, although I waivered on goving it an A- because the writing and the characters are so well done. I imagine when I get the audio someday it’ll be an A by virtue of Gary Furlong’s excellent narration! :-)