
Waiting for the Flood
Alexis Hall’s 30,000 word novella, Waiting for the Flood, was originally published in 2015 (AAR’s earlier DIK review is here), and, like Glitterland, has now been reissued as part of his ongoing publishing deal with Sourcebooks Casablanca. This new edition, however, has been substantially expanded to include a second, brand new, 50,000 word novella – Chasing the Light – which will not be released separately, so if you want to read it, you’ll have to purchase the new version. But it’s worth it, I promise.
In Waiting for the Flood, we meet Edwin Tully, a conservator at the Bodleian Library in Oxford.
Twelve years ago, Edwin Tully came to Oxford and fell in love with a boy named Marius. He was brilliant. An artist. It was going to be forever.
Two years ago, it ended.
Now Edwin lives alone in the house they used to share. He tends to damaged books and faded memories, trying to a build a future from the fragments of the past.
Two years after Marius left, Edwin is still alone, still struggling to move forward with his life. It’s not so much that he’s still in love with Marius or that he can’t accept that they’re over – it’s that he doesn’t understand why Marius left; nobody cheated, there were no flaming rows, just the quiet “click of a closing door”, the utter non-event-ness of it continually nagging away at his already shaky sense of self-esteem and reminding him that perhaps he just wasn’t worth staying for.
There’s a major flood alert in effect throughout the area, which is what throws civil engineer Adam Dacre into Edwin’s path. Adam is working with the Environment Agency to help manage the crisis and try to keep the damage to a minimum, and he’s exactly the sort of man you’d want to have your back in a tight spot – kind, calm, dependable and confident. He’s clearly interested in Edwin, but Edwin is still so scared of being hurt that he is unable to see beyond his fears to realise that the future he’d always longed for is staring him in the face and that it’s up to him to reach out and take it
Waiting for the Flood is a gentle and deeply moving story about coming to terms with grief, that is both melancholy and hopeful at the same time. The relationship between Edwin and Adam is superbly and convincingly developed, even though it happens over such a short space of time, and Edwin’s elderly neighbour, Mrs. P is a delightful mixture of mischief and wisdom.
I’ve always enjoyed Alexis Hall’s skill as a wordsmith. Some of his books hit the spot for me and some don’t, but the quality of his writing is never in question, and Waiting for the Flood is surely one of his highest achievements on that score. The writing is astonishingly beautiful – lyrical, insightful, painful, funny, truthful – and the way he uses the descriptions of Edwin’s home to mirror Edwin’s emotions is masterful. I often say that I’m not a big fan of novellas, but this is a rare exception – it’s something really special.
(Grade: A: Sensuality: Kisses)
Chasing the Light
Edwin’s ex, Marius Chankseliani, doesn’t appear in Waiting for the Flood, but has a strong presence in it nonetheless. Chasing the Light, which begins a few months or so after the events of Waiting for the Flood, brings him into sharper focus and reveals more about the complex, messed-up man who hurt Edwin so very deeply.
A mishap down by the river on Christmas Eve finds Marius alone, injured and unable to stand or walk. He doesn’t expect cursing loudly into the dark to be any use, but fortunately for him, help does arrive in the form of Leo, who lives on one of the narrowboats moored along the bank. He helps Marius aboard and proceeds to take care of him, wrapping Marius up in the kind of warm, tender care he normally hates – but which this time, he can’t bring himself to walk away from.
Although Marius is the cause of Edwin’s heartbreak, he doesn’t come across as a bad person in WftF, but rather as someone doesn’t know what he wants or needs in order to be happy – although when we finally meet him in person, there’s no denying he’s a bit of an arsehole. He’s extremely prickly, sarcastic and often mean, but it doesn’t take very long to see that he’s sad and lost and full of self-loathing, the hurtful words he so frequently spits out a mask to hide his vulnerable underbelly. He’s struggling to come to terms with something that is potentially life-altering and he pushes away anyone who tries to offer him the comfort he doesn’t feel he deserves and tells himself he doesn’t want.
Leo is a lovely man – thoughtful, kind, funny and comfortable in his own skin. He’s been through a lot but has finally found his place in life and his peace far away from the man he used to be, and his patience and understanding are exactly what Marius so desparately needs – although Marius would rather die than admit it. Once again, the relationship in the story develops quickly but it’s so well-crafted that it’s easy to believe that these two will find their way.
Both stories end in a very firm HFN, giving Edwin and Marius new starting points that offer the potential for future happiness. I liked the emphasis on love being nothing to do with worth; that everyone, no matter how messed up or how broken, deserves love, acceptance and to be seen by someone who gets them, and I also really appreciated the fact that Edwin and Marius finally get the opportunity to talk and achieve some closure.
(Grade: A; Sensuality: Warm)
Waiting for the Flood and Chasing the Light are perfect companion pieces featuring similar themes of heartbreak, loss, and recovery. The prose is beautiful and profound, the characters are endearing and their love stories are full of compassion and hope. Highly recommended.






Amazon e-book price just dropped to $2.99 for the updated version.
I listened to the Will Watt narration of these two stories, and he did a great job on both. I really enjoyed his characterizations and the way he differentiated each person. I loved WFTF, which has been a favorite of mine for its warmth, humor and creativity, as well as the lovely writing and the sweetness of the MC’s. I was concerned that I would not enjoy CTL because I was predisposed to dislike Marius, and in all honesty, I never really warmed up to him. While I sympathized with the big life change he is experiencing and its repercussions, his tendency to choose cruelty over kindness, again and again, made it hard for me to like his character. It sounded like the sarcasm and cruelty predated his life change, and his continued impatience with Edwin’s stuttering and kindness was a deal breaker for me. Leo, however, was lovely, and better than Marius deserved, as were his parents.
Of course, CTL is well-written by Hall, and I appreciated the conversation between Edwin and Marius toward the end, as it seemed it would help them both move on. I loved the epilogue where we got to spend more time with Edwin and Adam, who were just delightful with their teasing and problem solving and playful banter. For me WFTF remains an A, but CTL is a B+ for me.
This is my first AH book. Two DIK from two different reviewers propelled me into borrowing the book from the library. This was a 2015 edition with only WFTF. I agree with everything that the reviewers have said about the book. It is beautifully written and the prose is frequently more poetic and lyrical. The characters are believable and the HFN ending is realistic. Thanks for bringing this lovely novella to your readers’s attention.
Your library may update with the new edition, and I highly recommend getting it and reading Chasing the Light. It’s marvelous, too!
I’m so glad you enjoyed it. And if your library doesn’t get the new edition, I can confidently say that this is a book worth purchasing if that’s an option for you.
Ok, so I have to ask you, Caz. Do you really and truly believe that CtL is as good as WFTF? I feel like your review of WFTF indicates your belief that it is truly excellent, and I agree with you. I love that little piece of perfection. However, your review of CtL does not tell me why you think CtL is its equal. You gave them both A’s. Please explain!
For the same reasons, really. The beautiful, intuitive writing, the characterisation – especially Marius, who is a complicated mess, hard to like, but not once you get to see what’s driving him.
*
*
*
SPOILER: As well as the thing I mention in the he’s struggling with his sense of self – how can he call himself an artist when he hasn’t produced anything in ages?
*
*
*
Like Flood, it’s a story full of so many little acutely observed things that kind of worm their way into your brain and keep you thinking long after you’ve finished. It might not be quite the exquisite tour de force that Flood is, but I honestly couldn’t point to anything in Light that doesn’t work. And I have to agree with AH’s assertion that the two stories belong together ;)
FYI–an update messed up our spoiler plug. We are working on fixing it but right now, we can’t hide spoilers.
Bugger. So it applies to comments as well as posts. I’ll white it out or something.
ETA: Works in the source code but not in the published comment, Oh, well…
No worries, it doesn’t sound like that big of a spoiler! Thank you for elaborating, Caz. You are always very thorough in your reviews, and I really appreciate your thoughtfulness and your responsiveness! I definitely will be reading Marius’ story, even though I am predisposed to dislike him for hurting Edwin. Sounds like Hall works his magic and helps you to care about him and want him happy, too.
I hope you enjoy it – Marius is a prickly bugger, but there’s a fragility to him that comes through very strongly, and he becomes understandable and even likeable! Do come back and let me know what you think :)
I also think CtL is a little stronger even than WftF, but mostly, while it covers some of the same issues (grief, saddness, etc) and some things are the same ( Edwin appears here, etc.), it’s has a slightly different feel than WftF, which helped me not to directly compare them. For one thing, it’s significantly longer than WftF, which gives more room for character development and for the relationship between Marius and Leo to feel fleshed out. I also really wanted to see Edwin and Adam farther along in their relationship after reading WftF originally, and CtL does that. It rounds out both stories so well. I guess I would say Chasing the Light made Waiting for the Flood even stronger by adding slightly more depth to all the characters.
WftF still stands alone, even though your get more closure for the characters in CtL. But Chasing the Light relies on WftF for it’s grounding, in my opinion. I think, for me, these will always be two sides to the same coin.
I’ve ordered the paper version of this but have not read it yet. How is WFTF different from the original version? Or is it just the addition of Marius’ story?
Yes, Chasing the Light is new, and I think the new edition also includes a couple of recipes (Edwin’s Elderflower Wine & Marius’ Mum’s Pierogi) and the short story Aftermath. I say “I think” because they weren’t in my ARC, but they are in the audio version and audios are usually exact replicas of what’s in the text. According to AH’s website, CtL isn’t being published separately because the stories “belong together.”
AFAIK, there are no changes to the original story.
I highly recommend the audio btw – the narration is wonderful.
On the TBR!
I’m still thinking of these stories two weeks after listening to the audiobook (gorgeously narrated by Will Watt). The writing is so beautiful and powerful. Every word seems chosen with purpose and nothing is wasted. Novellas rarely feel as rich and satisfying as a full length novel due to the word count, but Hall pulls it off here. It’s rare (for me, anyway) to feel so completely immersed in a story. Will Watt’s narration is perfect and I can’t imagine anyone doing it better.
There’s such warmth and insight and humour to these stories. I just finished listening to the audio as well – Will Watt is (again) superb and absolutely nails their kind of dreamy, reflective quality.
Sorry, I’ve loved the Alexander Doddy audiobook of WFTF for years and years. It has been my favorite novella of all time since my first listen to WFTF. As much as I enjoyed Watt’s 10 Things That Never Happened, I’m bummed that Doddy was not available or chosen to perform this new edition.
It may be that he no longer narrates – his isn’t a name I’ve come across at all over the past few years. (I just had a look at Audible and he hasnt done anything since 2021.) Plus Will Watt was outstanding in 10 Things That Never Happened and I suspect AH requested him specifically, as he did Nicholas Boulton for Glitterland.
I agree that the Alexander Doddy version is excellent, and once I’m used to a certain narrator giving voice to a book, it’s hard to really wipe that mental slate clean in order to appreciate what a new narrator brings. Caz, thanks for checking on Doddy. If he’s no longer doing audiobooks, then obviously they needed to find someone else, and Watt sounds like a good choice.
I’m the same with narrators – on the rare occasion a book gets re-recorded with a different narrator, I get very huffy if the original was one I loved. I’d have been outraged if Glitterland had been re-recorded by anyone other than Nicholas Boulton! (I reviewed the new edition at AudioGals if you’re interested.)
But Will Watt more than does this justice – he really captures the kind of melancholic but hopeful atmosphere of the stories and his character voices are excellent. (He does a terrific job with Edwin’s stammer for instance, and Marius’ mother is a loveable hoot!)
I really enjoyed Doddy’s narration of the original, too, but I have to admit I can’t imagine anyone doing a better job than Watt does. He’s really phenomenal on this. If it bothers you, skip WftF and listen to his narration of CtL, since these are mostly new characters, and see what you think.
That is a great suggestion! I may just do so, since Caz says that WFTF hasn’t really changed all that much.
I’m trying to remember where I read it, but the author has said that there have been no changes to the text of Flood. And I’ll agree with Carrie that I really can’t imagine anyone doing a better job with it than Will Watt.