Desert Isle Keeper
I think most aspiring historical romance writers would like to be Julie Garwood when they grow up. I know I would. Her stories always give me a smile, a laugh and a tear. I love them all, but my favorite Garwood book has always been The Secret.
This book grabs you from the first page and never lets go, beginning when four year old Judith, an English girl, befriends four year old Frances Catherine, a Scots lass, at a border fair. Over the years, they share their deepest secrets. Frances Catherine fears giving birth, and when she becomes pregnant by her Highland husband, Patrick, she sends for Judith. Her husband’s brother, Laird Iain Maitland, is elected to fetch her. Iain believes Judith, being English, won’t honor her promise to Frances Catherine. To his surly surprise, he finds Judith waiting on her doorstep.
Iain immediately decides Judith will be difficult. And she is, but not in the way he expects. She’s polite, stubborn, sweet, tender-hearted, brave and beautiful. He’s used to women cowering at his slightest frown, but Judith stands up to him. He soon finds he can’t even look at her without being torn by desire. Desire for an Englishwoman? Impossible!
Judith also feels attracted to the huge, scowling Scots laird. Despite Iain’s bluster, she sees an intelligent man with a kind heart, an arrogant confidence in his abilities, and a fierce handsomeness that makes her heart pound!
When Iain decides a kiss will get her out of his system, it backfires. He wants her more than ever. Judith wants Iain to kiss her again. Even though they agree nothing can ever come of their attraction, desire and fate keep throwing them together.
For instance, one night Judith is awakened by Iain to assist an expectant mother birth her child – she’s heard from Frances Catherine that Judith won’t be as cruel as the local midwife. After the child is born, Judith cries all over Iain’s plaid and swears she’ll never, never do it again. Iain feels his love for Judith grow with each tear.
After this initial trial by fire, Judith finds she must confront additional fires, including being accused of sorcery by the now-jealous midwife, and assisting in the births of many women in the clan. Throughout Judith’s ordeals, Iain’s respect and love for her grow; he can’t bear the thought of Judith and any other man but him, and decides he will marry her. Iain’s proposal and the marriage ceremony are unlike any you will read; they are Garwood at her best. They are hilarious.
Iain’s responsibilities as laird are something Judith just doesn’t get. Those Scots do some strange things, and for the oddest of reasons! Still, Judith brings a breath of fresh air to the lives of her new Highland family, and the changes she convinces them to make better their lives.
Her suggestions, as they make their way through the clan’s leadership, are, again, Garwood at her best. Through sometimes tortuous logic, she convinces the leadership to change. These scenes are often hilarious and among my favorites. In turn, Iain’s clan becomes very loyal to Judith in ways she’d never expect. Meanwhile, with each display of bravery and thoughtfulness, Iain’s love for Judith continues to grow, and it scares the hell out of him, especially since he thinks he’s figured out her secret. As for Judith, her passion for Iain surprises her, but her past is filled with secrets that make it difficult to fully trust him. Again, in true Garwood fashion, this is handled with loving humor and is delightful to read.
In a romance, as we all know, the course of true love never does run smooth, and, because of the title, we know there’s a whopper of a secret just waiting to ruin the good thing Judith and Iain have going. I won’t give away the secret. Although the reader knows about it early on in the book, Iain doesn’t discover it for quite awhile, and it’s his discovery that could destroy his and Judith’s happiness.
Just when things look most grim, the author changes the tone with the birthing of Frances Catherine’s child. The delivery goes wrong, with the child coming out feet first. “Trust you to do everything backwards, Frances Catherine!” Judith yells. While the humor injected into the situation brings a respite to the unfolding drama of Judith’s secret, she doesn’t know what will become of her, and Iain’s actions and remarks don’t help matters much. The ending is too good to give away; you’ll have to read The Secret to find out!
I love The Secret best out of all of Julie Garwood’s books because this story shows how one woman can stand against prejudices of race, religion, custom and gender to change people’s minds. The relationship between Iain and Judith is always touching, always fresh, even after reading this story for what must be the tenth time! If you’ve never read Julie Garwood’s The Secret, or haven’t read it in a long time, pick it up the first chance you get. Believe me, it’s definitely a keeper.
Buy it at Amazon/Apple Books/Barnes and Noble/Kobo
Over the years, AAR has had many a guest reviewer. If we don't know the name of the reviewer, we've placed their reviews under this generic name.
|Review Date:||November 21, 2017|
|Book Type:||Medieval Romance|
|Review Tags:||midwife | Scotland | Top 100 Romance|
A top five when it comes to fave Garwoods; I remember this one being sweet and funny!
I’m an unabashed Garwood fan. Her simple uncomplicated heroes, heroines, and plots work for me in certain moods. I totally see her continue to be on the Top 100 list.
Garwood has never been an author who appeals to me as I find her books over simplistic and even kind of cutesy with a too precious and adorable heroine who manages to fix everything wrong in the new world she enters. In The Secret, as I recall, Judith is able to bring warring clans together that had been in conflict for centuries, a little like one person resolving historical Middle East tensions today. But I did like Iain, as he seemed more charming and intellectual than other Garwood heroes. I found the banter between Iain and Judith genuinely fun to read. I’ve never reread the book and wouldn’t but this one had entertaining moments.
Yet another classic I’ve not read. Is it a keeper?
I find Lion’s Lady is the Garwood that held up the best for me over the years. They all used to be among my favorites, particularly the Bride and the ones of that era. A lot of it reads kind of like screwball comedy with the heroine doing awkward things or saying things that doesn’t make sense to others. The Secret like The Bride plays on the “Englishwoman goes to Scotland where things are different” trope and has another Scotsman who doesn’t like The English but is won over and makes an exception for the heroine as the hero.
Lion’s Lady which is a Regency (The Secret and The Bride are nominally Medieval in setting) works better because of the heroine’s unusual upbringing so her mistakes with English (not her first language) make sense as she is very literal and her childhood was wildly different that that of a society Miss. It makes much more sense for a “fish out of water” story and the romance is quite charming. Garwood books are more gentle stories and you either enjoy the humor or you don’t. Some find them silly.
Garwood broke out in the early 90’s and at the time I really enjoyed them as a reaction to the often cruel, overly Alpha heroes that were big in the 1970-80’s but in my book they don’t overall hold up as DIK’s.